Editor’s Note: A graduate school admission essay should showcase an applicant’s unique experiences and qualities, highlighting their suitability for the program. This analysis of a personal description essay identifies strengths such as cultural background, language skills, diverse experiences, and professional growth. However, the essay could improve by focusing on specific examples, connecting past experiences to future goals, and illustrating personal growth. Key suggestions include narrowing the focus to 2-3 impactful experiences, explicitly linking the essay to the graduate program, and concluding with a statement that ties past achievements to future aspirations.
A Critical Evaluation of a Graduate School Admission Essay: Balancing Strengths and Opportunities for Improvement
Introduction
The personal statement is a crucial component of any graduate school application, serving as a window into the applicant’s character, experiences, and potential. This analysis aims to dissect the strengths and weaknesses of the given essay, providing a comprehensive evaluation of its effectiveness in showcasing the applicant’s suitability for graduate studies.
Strengths: A Tapestry of Global Experiences and Skills
Cultural Fluency and Linguistic Prowess
The essay masterfully weaves a narrative of rich cultural diversity, positioning the applicant as a true global citizen. Born in Brazil, raised by a French entrepreneur, and educated in the United States, the applicant embodies the internationalism that many graduate programs seek. This multicultural background is further enhanced by proficiency in four languages – English, French, Portuguese, and Spanish. In an era where global business acumen is paramount, these linguistic skills are not merely impressive; they are invaluable assets that set the applicant apart.
Multifaceted Excellence: Academics, Athletics, and Business
The applicant’s journey from a tennis scholarship recipient to an honors graduate in business administration illustrates a remarkable ability to balance competing demands. This duality of excellence in both sports and academics speaks volumes about the applicant’s time management skills, discipline, and ability to thrive under pressure – all crucial attributes for success in graduate studies and beyond.
Professional Trajectory and Entrepreneurial Spirit
The essay effectively charts the applicant’s professional growth, from internships with multinational corporations to founding a consulting company. This progression demonstrates not only ambition but also a proactive approach to career development. The mention of working with industry giants like Sony adds credibility to the applicant’s business acumen and hints at a network that could be valuable in graduate school and future endeavors.
Self-Awareness and Continuous Growth
Perhaps one of the most compelling aspects of the essay is the applicant’s self-reflection regarding personal strengths and weaknesses. The acknowledgment that qualities like directness and perfectionism can be double-edged swords shows a level of maturity and self-awareness that is highly prized in graduate programs. This introspection suggests an openness to feedback and a commitment to personal development – essential traits for academic and professional growth.
Areas for Enhancement: Refining the Narrative for Maximum Impact
Depth Over Breadth
While the essay successfully paints a broad picture of the applicant’s experiences, it falls short in providing the depth that truly captivates admissions committees. The narrative would benefit from focusing on fewer, more impactful experiences, delving into the challenges faced, lessons learned, and personal growth achieved. For instance, an in-depth exploration of how the applicant’s tennis career influenced their business acumen could provide a unique perspective on leadership and perseverance.
Bridging Past Experiences with Future Aspirations
A critical missing element in the essay is a clear articulation of how the applicant’s rich background aligns with their future goals and, more importantly, how graduate school fits into this trajectory. Without this connection, the impressive list of achievements risks appearing as a mere recitation of past accomplishments rather than a foundation for future growth.
Specificity and Anecdotal Evidence
The essay would be significantly strengthened by the inclusion of specific anecdotes that illustrate the applicant’s claims. For example, a brief story about a cross-cultural business negotiation that showcased the applicant’s linguistic and cultural adaptation skills would breathe life into the narrative and make the applicant’s qualities more memorable.
Contribution to the Graduate Program
While the essay effectively showcases what the applicant has achieved, it misses an opportunity to articulate how these unique experiences and perspectives would contribute to the diversity and richness of the graduate program. Admissions committees are keen to understand not just what the program can do for the applicant, but also what the applicant can bring to their cohort.
Conclusion: A Foundation for a Compelling Narrative
In sum, this essay presents a strong foundation for a compelling graduate school application. The applicant’s diverse international background, coupled with academic, athletic, and professional achievements, creates a profile of a well-rounded and ambitious individual. However, to truly stand out in the competitive landscape of graduate admissions, the essay needs refinement.
By focusing on depth rather than breadth, explicitly connecting past experiences to future goals, incorporating vivid anecdotes, and articulating potential contributions to the program, the applicant can transform this good essay into an outstanding one. The key lies in crafting a narrative that not only showcases achievements but also tells a cohesive story of growth, purpose, and future potential.
Ultimately, with these enhancements, the essay has the potential to present the applicant not just as a candidate with an impressive background, but as an individual poised to make significant contributions to their chosen field of study and beyond.
Work Cited
Barbara, T., Sullivan, J., & David, M. (1995). Global Perspective in Multinational Enterprises. Business Review Press.
Brewster, C., & Harris, H. (1999). “International HRM: Contemporary Issues in Europe”. Routledge.
Dowling, P. J., Festing, M., & Engle, A. D. (1999). International Human Resource Management: Managing People in a Multinational Context. Cengage Learning.
Gregersen, H. B., Black, J. S., & Mendenhall, M. E. (1996). “Multiple Perspectives on Expatriate Management.” International Journal of Human Resource Management, 7(2), 356-379. Taylor & Francis Online.
Mendenhall, M., & Oddou, G. (1991). “Cross-Cultural Training Effectiveness: A Review and Theoretical Framework for Future Research.” Academy of Management Review, 15(1), 113-136.
