Teacher’s Summary
Grade: A
This essay effectively explores the similarities and differences between the Elizabethan Era and today, using thoughtful comparisons that connect historical context to contemporary issues. The student demonstrates strong analytical skills and provides personal reflections that deepen the analysis. The essay is well-structured, with clear and concise arguments. To further enhance the work, the student could include more specific examples or primary sources from the Elizabethan period. Overall, this is an insightful and well-written essay that shows a strong understanding of historical parallels.
The Elizabethan Era and Today: A Student’s Perspective on Historical Similarities and Differences
Introduction
When I first started learning about the Elizabethan Era in my AP European History class, I was struck by how much has changed since then – but also by some surprising similarities to our modern world. As someone who’s always been fascinated by how the past shapes our present, I found myself drawing connections between Elizabethan society and our own. This essay explores these similarities and differences, reflecting on what they reveal about social progress and human nature.
Similarities: Bridging the Centuries
Education and Social Class
One of the first similarities I noticed was in education. Just as in Elizabethan times, access to quality education today often correlates with social class and economic status. While we’ve made significant strides in providing universal education, the reality is that educational opportunities can still vary greatly depending on one’s background.
This reminded me of discussions we’ve had in our school’s Social Justice Club about educational inequality. It’s sobering to realize that some of the same issues from over 400 years ago still persist today.
Childhood Principles
I was surprised to find that many basic principles of childhood in the Elizabethan Era sound familiar: respecting parents, having table manners, and starting education at home. It made me reflect on how some fundamental values in raising children have remained constant over centuries.
Inventions and Scientific Methods
Learning about Elizabethan inventions like the telescope and thermometer was fascinating. It’s amazing to think that we’re still using improved versions of these inventions today. The emergence of new scientific methods during this era, emphasizing observation and experimentation, laid the groundwork for modern scientific inquiry.
As a member of my school’s Science Club, I’m always excited to learn about the historical roots of scientific practices we use today. It gives me a deeper appreciation for the long journey of scientific discovery.
Urban Sanitation Challenges
Unfortunately, one similarity I wish didn’t exist is the ongoing struggle with sanitation in some urban areas. While we’ve made enormous progress since Elizabethan times, issues of waste management and disease control in densely populated areas remain challenges in many parts of the world.
This connection made me think about the importance of public health initiatives and urban planning, topics we’ve explored in my Environmental Science class.
Food and Social Status
The relationship between diet and social status in Elizabethan times bears a striking resemblance to modern food inequality. Just as the wealthy then had access to a wider variety of foods, today we see disparities in access to nutritious food based on socioeconomic status.
This similarity hit close to home for me. As a volunteer at our local food bank, I’ve seen firsthand how income levels can affect dietary options and nutrition.
Differences: Measuring Progress
Medical Knowledge and Practice
Perhaps the most striking difference is in medical knowledge and practice. The Elizabethan belief in humors and herbal remedies stands in stark contrast to our modern, evidence-based medical practices. It’s amazing to think how far we’ve come in understanding and treating diseases.
Learning about historical medical practices has given me a new appreciation for the medical care we have today. It also makes me excited about potential future advancements in medicine, a field I’m considering for my career.
Language and Communication
The evolution of the English language since Elizabethan times is fascinating. From changes in vocabulary and spelling to the expansion of the average person’s word usage, it’s clear that language is a living, evolving entity.
As someone who loves literature and participates in our school’s Poetry Club, I find it intriguing to trace how our language has changed over time. It makes me wonder how English might continue to evolve in the future.
Education System
Comparing the Elizabethan school week to our modern education system highlights significant changes in what we prioritize in learning. The focus on religious education and strict discipline has given way to a more diverse curriculum and student-centered approach.
This difference made me reflect on how education reflects societal values. It’s interesting to consider what aspects of our current education system future generations might find outdated.
Fashion and Clothing
The stark contrast in clothing between Elizabethan times and today is not just about style, but also about practicality and social signaling. While we still use clothing as a form of self-expression and status symbol, the extremes of Elizabethan fashion seem almost theatrical to us now.
As someone interested in fashion history, I find it fascinating to see how clothing trends reflect broader societal changes.
Social Norms and Equality
Perhaps the most significant difference is in social norms, particularly regarding gender equality and individual freedoms. The progress we’ve made in these areas since Elizabethan times is remarkable, though we still have work to do.
This difference is particularly meaningful to me as a young woman. It makes me grateful for the opportunities I have today while also inspiring me to continue working towards greater equality for all.
Life Expectancy
The dramatic increase in life expectancy since Elizabethan times is a testament to advancements in medicine, nutrition, and overall quality of life. It’s sobering to think that many people in Elizabethan England didn’t live past their teenage years.
This difference really puts into perspective how much human society has progressed and makes me appreciate the longevity we often take for granted today.
Conclusion
Comparing the Elizabethan Era to our present day has been an illuminating exercise. It’s shown me how far we’ve come in many areas, from medicine to social equality, while also highlighting some persistent challenges.
This exploration has reinforced for me the importance of studying history. By understanding where we’ve come from, we can better appreciate our progress and identify areas where we still need to improve. It’s also a reminder that while times change, many aspects of human nature and society remain constant.
As I continue my studies and look towards my future, I’m inspired by the progress humanity has made since Elizabethan times. At the same time, I’m motivated to address the challenges that persist, hoping that future generations will look back on our era and see similar strides in progress and understanding.
References
•“The Elizabethan Era”. (n.d.). Retrieved from History.com
•“Life in Elizabethan England”. (n.d.). Retrieved from Britannica
•“Social Class in Elizabethan England”. (n.d.). Retrieved from Shakespeare Online
•“The Evolution of Medicine from the Elizabethan Era to Today”. (n.d.). Retrieved from National Institutes of Health